Very revealing comparison. I think the Witnesses teaching made a monkey out of me until my thinking evolved. When I was in high school I took the evolution book and tried to prove to my biology teacher the creationist view. I realized then that the Witnesses argument was an over simplification as the teacher's case held so much more detailed evidence, I felt a little silly.
If the creationists are going to mess with the theory of evolution as it's taught in the public schools they need to make a much stronger case than the witnesses did back then.
I think the religions in the United States should just leave science alone, from what I have experienced science pursues 'the truth' and the religions pursue the money. Charles Darwin wins this contest, Charles Russell looks like a nut.